Calls To Introduce Speed Limit Devices

Posted on: 05 January 2009 by Gareth Hargreaves

Automatic speed control devices should be installed in cars to force motorists to stick to speed limits, an influential pressure group has recommended.

The Commission for Integrated Transport (CfIT), a government transport advisory group, has said that up to 29% of injury accidents on the road could be prevented by the voluntary introduction of intelligent speed adaption (ISA).

The system, which the report recommended drivers installing on a voluntary and not compulsory basis, would automatically slow a car down to within the limit for the individual road on which it is being driven.

However opponents of the report, co-written by the pressure-group Motorists Forum, claimed the idea was dangerous as drivers would enter "zombie" mode, where they fail to pay proper attention to road conditions.

The report, which also looked at the impacts on fuel consumption, emissions, noise and road network efficiency, concluded that, on 70mph roads, adherence to the speed limit could also lead to savings of up to 6% in CO2 emissions as well as reduce accidents.

It called for the Department for Transport to work with the relevant authorities, organisations and vehicle manufacturers to consider what steps should be taken to support and encourage the future availability of the technology and to promote its take-up.

“This important report shows the very real benefits to motorists from the introduction and use of an ISA system - not just in road safety but also in terms of fuel and money saved," says CfIT vice-chairman David Leeder.

Sir Trevor Chinn, chairman of the Motorists’ Forum, says the UK has an enviable record on road safety but also pointed towards the fact nearly 3,000 people are still killed on Britain’s roads each year.

“This report shows the potential substantial savings in injury accidents that could be achieved through the introduction of ISA.

“The fact that the report is backed by our members, who represent interests across the motoring spectrum, is testimony to the desire of the motoring world to work with government to make our roads even safer,” he says.

However, the proposals were immediately criticised, with some saying the devices would potentially numb drivers' reactions to road conditions.

Claire Armstrong, from the road safety charity Safe Speed, told the BBC that the device would be "highly dangerous" for driver reactions. "You've taken the responsibility away from the driver," she says.

Derek Charters, from the Motor Industry Research Association, added "The last thing you need is one car to be overtaking and then pull back in, in front of the cars in front, because that braking event will then cause everybody to start to slow down, which will then compress the traffic, which then causes an incident."

Who do you agree with? Should speed limiters be made compulsory in all UK cars?

Let us know by leaving a comment in the box below or share your thoughts with other readers in the 50connect forums.

Share with friends


You need to be signed in to rate.